Although I could have used ssh-copy-id to copy my new SSH public key to all of my old servers, I liked the idea of maintaining separate "personal" and "work" identities and decided to look for a way to automatically use the right key based on the server I was trying to connect to.
For the first few days I was specifying my new identity on the command line using:
ssh -i .ssh/endpoint_rsa email@example.com
That worked, but I often forgot to specify my new SSH identity when connecting to a server, only realizing my mistake when I was prompted for a password instead of being authenticated automatically.
I had previously learned the value of creating an ssh_config file when I replaced a series of command-line aliases with equivalent entries in the SSH config file.
Instead of creating aliases in my shell:
alias server1='ssh -p 2222 -L 3389:192.168.1.99:3389 firstname.lastname@example.org'
I learned that I could add an equivalent entry to my ~/.ssh/config file:
Host server1 HostName server1.example.com Port 2222 User patrick LocalForward 3389 192.168.1.99:3389
Then, to connect to that server, all I needed to do was run ssh server1 and all of the configuration details would be pulled in from the SSH config file. Replacing my series of shell aliases with Host definitions had the added benefit of automatically carrying over to other tools like git and mosh which read the same configuration.
Switching Identities Automatically
There's an easy solution to managing multiple SSH identities if you only use one identity per server; use ssh-add to store all of your keys in the SSH authentication agent. For example, I used ssh-add ~/.ssh/endpoint_rsa to add my new key, and ssh-add -l to verify that it was showing up in the list of known keys. After adding all of your keys to the agent, it will automatically try them in order for SSH connections until it finds one that authenticates successfully.
Manually Defining Identities
If you need more control over which identity an SSH session is using, the IdentityFile option in ssh_config lets you specify which key will be used to authenticate. Here's an example:
Host server2 HostName server2.example.com User patrick IdentityFile ~/.ssh/endpoint_rsa
This usage is particularly helpful when you have a server that accepts more than one of your identities and you need to control which one should be used.