Welcome to End Point’s blog

Ongoing observations by End Point people

Liquid Galaxy at The Ocean Conference

End Point had the privilege of participating in The Ocean Conference at the United Nations, hosted by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN), these past two weeks. The health of the oceans is critical, and The Ocean Conference, the first United Nations conference on this issue, presents a unique and invaluable opportunity for the world to reverse the precipitous decline of the health of the oceans and seas with concrete solutions.

A Liquid Galaxy was set up in a prominent area on the main floor of the United Nations. End Point created custom content for the Ocean Conference, using the Liquid Galaxy’s Content Management System. Visiting diplomats and government officials were able to experience this content - Liquid Galaxy’s interactive panoramic setup allows visitors to feel immersed in the different locations, with video and information spanning their periphery.

Liquid Galaxy content created for The Ocean Conference included:
-A study of the Catlin Seaview Survey and how the world's coral reefs are changing
-360 panoramic underwater videos
-All Mission Blue Ocean Hope Spots
-A guided tour of the Monaco Explorations 3 Year Expedition
-National Marine Sanctuaries around the United States

We were grateful to be able to create content for such a good cause, and hope to be able to do more good work for the IUCN and the UN! If you’d like to learn more, please visit our website or email

Successful First GEOINT Symposium for End Point Liquid Galaxy

This past week, End Point attended GEOINT Symposium to showcase Liquid Galaxy as an immersive panoramic GIS solution to GEOINT attendees and exhibitors alike.

At the show, we showcased Cesium integrating with ArcGIS and WMS, Google Earth, Street View, Sketchfab, Unity, and panoramic video. Using our Content Management System, we created content around these various features so visitors to our booth could take in the full spectrum of capabilities that the Liquid Galaxy provides.

Additionally, we were able to take data feeds for multiple other booths and display their content during the show! Our work served to show everyone at the conference that the Liquid Galaxy is a data-agnostic immersive platform that can handle any sort of data stream and offer data in a brilliant display. This can be used to show your large complex data sets in briefing rooms, conference rooms, or command centers.

Given the incredible draw of the Liquid Galaxy, the GEOINT team took special interest in our system and formally interviewed Ben Goldstein in front of the system to learn more! You can view the video of the interview here:

We look forward to developing the relationships we created at GEOINT, and hope to participate further in this great community moving forward. If you would like to learn more please visit our website or email

Amazon AWS upgrades to Postgres with Bucardo

Many of our clients at End Point are using the incredible Amazon Relational Database Service (RDS), which allows for quick setup and use of a database system. Despite minimizing many database administration tasks, some issues still exist, one of which is upgrading. Getting to a new version of Postgres is simple enough with RDS, but we've had clients use Bucardo to do the upgrade, rather than Amazon's built-in upgrade process. Some of you may be exclaiming "A trigger-based replication system just to upgrade?!"; while using it may seem unintuitive, there are some very good reasons to use Bucardo for your RDS upgrade:

Minimize application downtime

Many businesses are very sensitive to any database downtime, and upgrading your database to a new version always incurs that cost. Although RDS uses the ultra-fast pg_upgrade --links method, the whole upgrade process can take quite a while - or at least too long for the business to accept. Bucardo can reduce the application downtime from around seven minutes to ten seconds or less.

Upgrade more than one version at once

As of this writing (June 2017), RDS only allows upgrading of one major Postgres version at a time. Since pg_upgrade can easily handle upgrading older versions, this limitation will probably be fixed someday. Still, it means even more application downtime - to the tune of seven minutes for each major version. If you are going from 9.3 to 9.6 (via 9.4 and 9.5), that's at least 21 minutes of application downtime, with many unnecessary steps along the way. The total time for Bucardo to jump from 9.3 to 9.6 (or any major version to another one) is still under ten seconds.

Application testing with live data

The Bucardo upgrade process involves setting up a second RDS instance running the newer version, copying the data from the current RDS server, and then letting Bucardo replicate the changes as they come in. With this system, you can have two "live" databases you can point your applications to. With RDS, you must create a snapshot of your current RDS, upgrade *that*, and then point your application to the new (and frozen-in-time) database. Although this is still useful for testing your application against the newer version of the database, it is not as useful as having an automatically-updated version of the database.

Control and easy rollback

With Bucardo, the initial setup costs, and the overhead of using triggers on your production database, is balanced a bit by ensuring you have complete control over the upgrade process. The migration can happen when you want, at a pace you want, and can even happen in stages as you point some of the applications in your stack to the new version, while keeping some pointed at the old. And rolling back is as simple as pointing apps back at the older version. You could even set up Bucardo as "master-master", such that both new and old versions can write data at the same time (although this step is rarely necessary).

Database bloat removal

Although the pg_upgrade program that Amazon RDS uses for upgrading is extraordinarily fast and efficient, the data files are seldom, if ever, changed at all, and table and index bloat is never removed. On the other hand, an upgrade system using Bucardo creates the tables from scratch on the new database, and thus completely removes all historical bloat. (Indeed, one time a client thought something had gone wrong, as the new version's total database size had shrunk radically - but it was simply removal of all table bloat!).

Statistics remain in place

The pg_upgrade program currently has a glaring flaw - no copying of the information in the pg_statistic table. Which means that although an Amazon RDS upgrade completes in about seven minutes, the performance will range somewhere from slightly slow to completely unusable, until all those statistics are regenerated on the new version via the ANALYZE command. How long this can take depends on a number of factors, but in general, the larger your database, the longer it will take - a database-wide analyze can take hours on very large databases. As mentioned above, upgrading via Bucardo relies on COPYing the data to a fresh copy of the table. Although the statistics also need to be created when using Bucardo, the time cost for this does NOT apply to the upgrade time, as it can be done any time earlier, making the effective cost of generating statistics zero.

Upgrading RDS the Amazon way

Having said all that, the native upgrade system for RDS is very simple and fast. If the drawbacks above do not apply to you - or can be suffered with minimal business pain - then this way should always be the upgrade approach to use. Here is a quick walk through of how an Amazon RDS upgrade is done.

For this example, we will create a new Amazon RDS instance. The creation is amazingly simple: just log into, choose RDS, choose PostgreSQL (always the best choice!), and then fill in a few details, such as preferred version, server size, etc. The "DB Engine Version" was set as PostgreSQL 9.3.16-R1", the "DB Instance Class" as db.t2.small -- 1 vCPU, 2 GiB RAM, and "Multi-AZ Deployment" as no. All other choices are the default. To finish up this section of the setup, "DB Instance Identifier" was set to gregtest, the "Master Username" to greg, and the "Master Password" to b5fc93f818a3a8065c3b25b5e45fec19

Clicking on "Next Step" brings up more options, but the only one that needs to change is to specify the "Database Name" as gtest. Finally, the "Launch DB Instance" button. The new database is on the way! Select "View your DB Instance" and then keep reloading until the "Status" changes to Active.

Once the instance is running, you will be shown a connection string that looks like this: That standard port is not a problem, but who wants to ever type that hostname out, or even have to look at it? The pg_service.conf file comes to the rescue with this new entry inside the ~/.pg_service.conf file:


Now we run a quick test to make sure psql is able to connect, and that the database is an Amazon RDS database:

$ psql service=gtest -Atc "show rds.superuser_variables"

We want to use the pgbench program to add a little content to the database, just to give the upgrade process something to do. Unfortunately, we cannot simply feed the "service=gtest" line to the pgbench program, but a little environment variable craftiness gets the job done:

$ export PGSERVICEFILE=/home/greg/.pg_service.conf PGSERVICE=gtest
$ pgbench -i -s 4
NOTICE:  table "pgbench_history" does not exist, skipping
NOTICE:  table "pgbench_tellers" does not exist, skipping
NOTICE:  table "pgbench_accounts" does not exist, skipping
NOTICE:  table "pgbench_branches" does not exist, skipping
creating tables...
100000 of 400000 tuples (25%) done (elapsed 0.66 s, remaining 0.72 s)
200000 of 400000 tuples (50%) done (elapsed 1.69 s, remaining 0.78 s)
300000 of 400000 tuples (75%) done (elapsed 4.83 s, remaining 0.68 s)
400000 of 400000 tuples (100%) done (elapsed 7.84 s, remaining 0.00 s)
set primary keys...

At 68MB in size, this is still not a big database - so let's create a large table, then create a bunch of databases, to make pg_upgrade work a little harder:

## Make the whole database 1707 MB:
$ psql service=gtest -c "CREATE TABLE extra AS SELECT * FROM pgbench_accounts"
SELECT 400000
$ for i in {1..5}; do psql service=gtest -qc "INSERT INTO extra SELECT * FROM extra"; done

## Make the whole cluster about 17 GB:
$ for i in {1..9}; do psql service=gtest -qc "CREATE DATABASE gtest$i TEMPLATE gtest" ; done
$ psql service=gtest -c "SELECT pg_size_pretty(sum(pg_database_size(oid))) FROM pg_database WHERE datname ~ 'gtest'"
17 GB

To start the upgrade, we log into the AWS console, and choose "Instance Actions", then "Modify". Our only choices for instances are "9.4.9" and "9.4.11", plus some older revisions in the 9.3 branch. Why anything other than the latest revision in the next major branch (i.e. 9.4.11) is shown, I have no idea! Choose 9.4.11, scroll down to the bottom, choose "Apply Immediately", then "Continue", then "Modify DB Instance". The upgrade has begun!

How long will it take? All one can do is keep refreshing to see when your new database is ready. As mentioned above, 7 minutes and 30 seconds is the total time. The logs show how things break down:

11:52:43 DB instance shutdown
11:55:06 Backing up DB instance
11:56:12 DB instance shutdown
11:58:42 The parameter max_wal_senders was set to a value incompatible with replication. It has been adjusted from 5 to 10.
11:59:56 DB instance restarted
12:00:18 Updated to use DBParameterGroup default.postgres9.4

How much of that time is spent on upgrading though? Surprisingly little. We can do a quick local test to see how long the same database takes to upgrade from 9.3 to 9.4 using pg_upgrade --links: 20 seconds! Ideally Amazon will improve upon the total downtime at some point.

Upgrading RDS with Bucardo

As an asynchronous, trigger-based replication system, Bucardo is perfect for situations like this where you need to temporarily sync up two concurrent versions of Postgres. The basic process is to create a new Amazon RDS instance of your new Postgres version (e.g. 9.6), install the Bucardo program on a cheap EC2 box, and then have Bucardo replicate from the old Postgres version (e.g. 9.3) to the new one. Once both instances are in sync, just point your application to the new version and shut the old one down. One way to perform the upgrade is detailed below.

Some of the steps are simplified, but the overall process is intact. First, find a temporary box for Bucardo to run on. It doesn't have to be powerful, or have much disk space, but as network connectivity is important, using an EC2 box is recommended. Install Postgres (9.6 or better, because of pg_dump) and Bucardo (latest or HEAD recommended), then put your old and new RDS databases into your pg_service.conf file as "rds93" and "rds96" to keep things simple.

The next step is to make a copy of the database on the new Postgres 9.6 RDS database. We want the bare minimum schema here: no data, no triggers, no indexes, etc. Luckily, this is simple using pg_dump:

$ pg_dump service=rds93 --section=pre-data | psql -q service=rds96

From this point forward, no DDL should be run on the old server. We take a snapshot of the post-data items right away and save it to a file for later:

$ pg_dump service=rds93 --section=post-data -f

Time to get Bucardo ready. Recall that Bucardo can only replicate tables that have a primary key or unique index. But if those tables are small enough, you can simply copy them over at the final point of migration later.

$ bucardo install
$ bucardo add db A dbservice=rds93
$ bucardo add db B dbservice=rds96
## Create a sync and name it 'migrate_rds':
$ bucardo add sync migrate_rds tables=all dbs=A,B

That's it! The current database will now have triggers that are recording any changes made, so we may safely do a bulk copy to the new database. This step might take a very long time, but that's not a problem.

$ pg_dump service=rds93 --section=data | psql -q service=rds96

Before we create the indexes on the new server, we start the Bucardo sync to copy over any rows that were changed while the pg_dump was going on. After that, the indexes, primary keys, and other items can be created:

$ bucardo start
$ tail -f log.bucardo ## Wait until the sync finishes once
$ bucardo stop
$ psql service=rds96 -q -f 

For the final migration, we simply stop anything from writing to the 9.3 database, have Bucardo perform a final sync of any changed rows, and then point your application to the 9.6 database. The whole process can happen very quickly: well under a minute for most cases.

Upgrading major Postgres versions is never a trivial task, but both Bucardo and pg_upgrade allow it to be orders of magnitude faster and easier than the old method of using the pg_dump utility. Upgrading your Amazon AWS Postgres instance is fast and easy using the AWS pg_upgrade method, but it has limitations, so having Bucardo help out can be a very useful option.

Series Digital joins End Point!

End Point has the pleasure to announce some very big news!

After an amicable wooing period, End Point has purchased the software consulting company Series Digital, a NYC-based firm that designs and builds custom software solutions. Over the past decade, Series Digital has automated business processes, brought new ideas to market, and built large-scale dynamic infrastructure.

Series Digital website snapshotSeries Digital launched in 2006 in New York City. From the start, Series Digital managed large database installations for financial services clients such as Goldman Sachs, Merrill Lynch, and Citigroup. They also worked with startups including, Byte, Mode Analytics, Domino, and Brewster.

These growth-focused, data-intensive businesses benefited from Series Digital’s expertise in scalable infrastructure, project management, and information security. Today, Series Digital supports clients across many major industry sectors and has focused its development efforts on the Microsoft .NET ecosystem. They have strong design and user experience expertise. Their client list is global.

The Series Digital team began working at End Point on April 3rd, 2017.

The CEO of Series Digital is Jonathan Blessing. He joins End Point’s leadership team as Director of Client Engagements. End Point has had a relationship with Jonathan since 2010, and looks forward with great anticipation to the role he will play expanding End Point’s consulting business.

To help support End Point’s expansion into .NET solutions, End Point has hired Dan Briones, a 25-year veteran of IT infrastructure engineering, to serve as Project and Team Manager for the Series Digital group. Dan started working with End Point at the end of March.

The End Point leadership team is very excited by the addition of Dan, Jonathan, and the rest of the talented Series Digital team: Jon Allen, Ed Huott, Dylan Wooters, Vasile Laur, Liz Flyntz, Andrew Grosser, William Yeack, and Ian Neilsen.

End Point’s reputation has been built upon its excellence in e-commerce, managed infrastructure, and database support. We are excited by the addition of Series Digital, which both deepens those abilities, and allows us to offer new services.

Talk to us to hear about the new ways we can help you!